How You Feel About the Silent Treatment, Based On Your Myers-Briggs® Personality Type
The silent treatment. We all hate being on the receiving end of it. Some of us give it because we need time to process our feelings. Others give it because they want to manipulate or regain a sense of power. In today’s article, we’re going to examine how each type responds to the dreaded silent treatment. Prepare to embark on a journey that might sometimes make you laugh, but also gain a fresh perspective on how different personalities interpret the silence.
Not sure what your personality type is? Take our thorough personality questionnaire here. Or you can take the official Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI®) here.
The INTJ
The INTJ, or as many call them, the “Masterminds,” have a unique take on the silent treatment. Annoying? Sure. Manipulative? Absolutely. But if you think you can out-silence an INTJ, you’re in for a surprise. They might find your silent treatment as pleasant as a mosquito at a summer barbecue, but they’re more than equipped to fight fire with fire. Or in this case, silence with more silence. They’ll sit back, fold their arms, and raise an eyebrow in a challenge. A wordless game of chicken, if you will. And trust me, they have the mental stamina to keep playing this uncomfortable game of silence-tac-toe for longer than you’d ever expect.
How the INTJ’s Cognitive Functions Feel About the Silent Treatment:
Introverted Intuition (Ni): “Hmm….your silence gives me the perfect opportunity to read between the lines or philosophize about the cosmic significance of the latest book I read. While we’re not chattering my mind is free to find patterns, meanings, and significance.”
Extraverted Thinking (Te): “The silent treatment? Really? Talk about a waste of valuable time! If there’s an issue, let’s lay it out on the table, dissect it, and find a solution. Fast. This isn’t a soap opera, it’s real life.”
Introverted Feeling (Fi): “I see you’re trying to silence me into submission. Talk about manipulative and insincere. You need time to figure out your feelings? Just say it. No need for this silent warfare.”
Extraverted Sensing (Se): “Alright, let’s figure out what’s really going on here. I’m scanning your body language, your facial expressions, taking in every detail in the environment. Are your arms crossed? Are you avoiding eye contact? I’m piecing together the clues here, looking for the cold, hard facts.”
Find out more about INTJs: 12 Awkward Moments INTJs Absolutely Hate
The INFJ
The INFJ, lovingly referred to as the “Mystic,” will likely take the silent treatment as well as a cat takes to a cold bath. As highly sensitive and empathetic individuals, they might see the silent treatment as a cross between a personal affront and a Sudoku puzzle. They’ll mull over every possible reason for your silence, probably inventing a few new ones along the way. But don’t think you can simply stonewall an INFJ without repercussions. They might be hurt, they might be confused, but they’re also resilient and, after asking you “are you okay?” and “what’s going on?” a few times, they won’t hesitate to use their silence launching retaliatory silence missiles. It’s a silent showdown of Clint Eastwood proportions.
How the INFJ’s Cognitive Functions Feel About the Silent Treatment:
Introverted Intuition (Ni): “Silent treatment? Intriguing. Let me delve into the depths of my psyche to understand what led you here. I’ll consider what’s going on beneath the surface of your stoic demeanor. I’ll gaze into your soul until you admit defeat and tell me what’s going on.”
Extraverted Feeling (Fe): “Silence is like a foggy window pane, obscuring clear communication. But, let’s find the silver lining in this cloud of quiet. We’re all about empathy and understanding here, so let’s consider your feelings too. Maybe this is your way of coping. Still, a heads up would have been nice.”
Introverted Thinking (Ti): “Listen, I crave precision and clarity, and this…this is ambiguity wrapped in a conundrum, sealed in a paradox. This isn’t a mime show, it’s a relationship. Manipulation doesn’t go down well with me. Let’s map it out, analyze it, and get to a resolution. Pronto!”
Extraverted Sensing (Se): “Your silence has a rhythm, a beat. I’m picking up every subtle change in your demeanor, every twitch of your eye. Every sigh will be noted and catalogued for future analysis. Keep that silence coming; we’re getting quite a lot from it.”
Learn more about INFJs: The Dark Side of the INFJ Personality Type
The ENTJ
The ENTJ, or as they are aptly called “The Commander,” has about as much patience for the silent treatment as a speeding bullet has for air resistance. It’s a non-starter, a no-go, a deal-breaker. ENTJs are all about action, strategy, and forward movement. The silent treatment is about as appealing to them as a stalled car in the fast lane. If you think you can mute an ENTJ into submission, you need to think again. They see this tactic as inefficient, emotionally messy, and frankly, rather childish. Mature ENTJs will understand that sometimes people need space and time to process their feelings, but if there’s any tinge of manipulation to it they’ll get really turned off and possibly angry.
How the ENTJ’s Cognitive Functions Feel About the Silent Treatment:
Extraverted Thinking (Te): “Silent treatment? Good luck with that! I don’t have time for these time-wasting games. If you have an issue, lay it out and let’s strategize a solution. If not, I’ve got a world to conquer and you’re not on the itinerary.”
Introverted Intuition (Ni): “While your silence has me considering the bigger picture, it’s not conducive to our common goal. I’m preoccupied with the future, not stuck in this trivial moment of silence.”
Extraverted Sensing (Se): “I’m aware of your silence, but it’s not affecting me the way you anticipate. I’m focused on action and what’s happening now. If you’re not contributing to it, you’re just unnecessary noise… or lack thereof.”
Introverted Feeling (Fi): “Your silent treatment doesn’t align with my values. Authenticity and sincerity are key, and your silence is neither. I respect those who communicate openly. Anything else is a waste of my time.”
Discover more about ENTJs: 24 Signs That You’re an ENTJ, the Director Personality Type
The ENFJ
As the affectionately named “Giver”, the ENFJ’s reaction to the silent treatment is like a meticulous host encountering an ungrateful guest. ENFJs thrive on harmony, understanding, and intimacy, and the silent treatment is a big, fat, neon-lit roadblock in their path to mutual understanding. For an ENFJ, silence isn’t golden; it’s a minefield of uncertainty. They’re likely to be deeply unsettled by it, but being the empathetic souls they are, they’ll attempt to understand your perspective. They’ll ask if you’re okay, what they did wrong, and how they can make things right. Just don’t mistake their kindness for weakness – they know their worth, and they won’t tolerate being taken for granted for long.
How the ENFJ’s Cognitive Functions Feel About the Silent Treatment:
Extraverted Feeling (Fe): “Silent treatment? Uncool. But let me put myself in your shoes. Maybe you’re hurting. Maybe you’re confused. Just know, I’m here when you decide to speak up. We ENFJs prefer a good heart-to-heart over this silent standoff.”
Introverted Intuition (Ni): “With every moment of silence, I’m delving deeper into the possible reasons behind your quiet. I am creating a mind-map of potential triggers, trying to figure out the root cause. I just wish you’d help me navigate this silence.”
Extraverted Sensing (Se): “I can see the change in your body language, the quiet unease in your eyes. Every inch of you is laden with clues. I’m observing every detail, hoping for better clarity.”
Introverted Thinking (Ti): “Your silence is a puzzle, and I’m keen to solve it. I’m aligning all the facts, analyzing your behavior pre-silence and now. I just hope we find a solution soon. This standoff is draining.”
Find out more about ENFJs: 10 Signs of an Unhealthy ENFJ
The INTP
The INTP, also known as “The Thinker”, is an intriguing blend of curiosity, intellect, and quiet depth. When confronted with the silent treatment, they are just as likely to interpret it as you needing some space and using the opportunity to immerse themselves in their latest intellectual pursuit, as they are to start over-analyzing the situation. Silence, for INTPs, can trigger a mental expedition, journeying through the labyrinth of possible scenarios and probabilities. However, the beauty of this introspective voyage is that it often leads them to logical clarity – even if it’s not always the clarity you may have intended.
How the INTP’s Cognitive Functions Feel About the Silent Treatment:
Introverted Thinking (Ti): “You’re silent, and that’s stirring my analytical side. I’m trying to deduce the logic behind your behavior, but it’s like decoding a cipher without a key. Maybe you need some time to yourself. If that’s the case, fine by me! I’ve got a backlog of fascinating theories to explore, a world of ideas to get lost in.”
Extraverted Intuition (Ne): “Your silence has sparked a brainstorm. Could it mean this? Or, perhaps, that? The hypotheses are multiplying.”
Introverted Sensing (Si): “I’m accurately cataloging each moment of silence, comparing it to past instances. Each sigh, each glance, is a piece of a larger puzzle.”
Inferior Extraverted Feeling (Fe): “I can perceive the emotional undercurrents in your silence, and it bewilders me. I’m caught in this tug-of-war between wanting to fix the situation and fearing I might exacerbate it.”
Find out more about INTPs: The Dark Side of the INTP Personality Type
The INFP
Known as “The Dreamer,” the INFP has a natural respect for personal processing time, recognizing the need for introspection and quiet contemplation. To them, silence is just another form of communication – a powerful one at that. When met with the silent treatment, they may initially interpret it as you needing some time to introspect, and they’re more than willing to extend that space. However, if this silence morphs into a manipulative tool, the INFP’s love for authenticity takes a hit. They value genuine emotions and clear intent, so playing silent games to control or hurt them is a direct affront to their core values.
How the INFP’s Cognitive Functions Feel About the Silent Treatment:
Introverted Feeling (Fi): “I understand the need for space and silence to process emotions. Yet, if it’s a ploy to manipulate, it goes against my core values of authenticity and sincerity. Express your feelings, no matter how messy they might be. Authenticity is always respected.”
Extraverted Intuition (Ne): “Trying to decipher the reason behind your silence, I may get lost in a sea of possibilities. Yet, I’m hoping for a positive resolution, a silver lining to this cloud of silence.”
Introverted Sensing (Si): “I might be recalling similar instances of silence from the past. Each episode provides context and aids in understanding the present situation. But remember, every silent moment is recorded and will not be overlooked.”
Extraverted Thinking (Te): “While I can rationalize the need for silence, I cannot fathom its use as a weapon. Let’s clear the air and communicate openly. That’s the best way”
Discover more about INFPs: 3 Weird and Wonderful Secrets of the INFP Personality Type
The ENTP
Known as “The Trailblazer”, the ENTP thrives on logical sparring and the exchange of ideas. A silent treatment, to them, is the conversational equivalent of a flat tire. In the face of such a communication breakdown, they’re likely to respond with a mix of intrigue, frustration, and a dash of dramatic flair. They get it, maybe you don’t know what you’re feeling yet! This is usually what happens to ENTPs when they give the silent treatment. They just aren’t sure what’s going on inside for them emotionally and it feels like a big, tangled mess. But on the receiving end, ENTPs see silent treatment less as a peaceful pause and more an illogical limbo, a frustrating game of charades with no clear rules.
How the ENTP’s Cognitive Functions Feel About the Silent Treatment:
Extraverted Intuition (Ne): “Ah, silence. An intriguing challenge. Are you upset? Are you just tired? Is this a cryptic hint that I should’ve remembered your great aunt’s birthday? The possibilities are as endless as they are perplexing.”
Introverted Thinking (Ti): “In the grand scheme of logical communicative methods, silent treatment ranks rather low. It’s like trying to solve a mathematical equation with abstract art. It just doesn’t add up. But worry not, I shall crack this code!”
Extraverted Feeling (Fe): “Reading emotions is a skill I can tap into rather well. I don’t like that you seem mad at me and want to get us back on the right footing, but I also kind of want to tease you for this manipulative ploy.”
Introverted Sensing (Si): “Remember that time when we disagreed on whether a tomato is a fruit or vegetable, and you went silent? Is this similar? Or perhaps it’s like that other time when… oh, never mind. The silent treatment is as confusing as it is vexing.”
Find out more about ENTPs: 10 Things You Should Never Say to an ENTP
The ENFP
ENFPs have a lot of patience when it comes to reflection and introspection, but zero tolerance for passive-aggressive manipulation. When hit with the silent treatment, their first thought might be, “Oh, solitude! Time for deep thoughts and world-changing ideas!” But soon enough, they realize it’s more of a cold shoulder than a contemplative retreat. Then, it’s game on. They might even adopt silence as their weapon, not to manipulate, but to make a point, much like a Shakespearean actor pausing dramatically during a performance. However, in the grand scheme of things, they’d rather break the ice than prolong the frostiness.
How the ENFP’s Cognitive Functions Feel About the Silent Treatment:
Extraverted Intuition (Ne): “Ah, the silent treatment! Are we playing the ‘Who Can Stay Silent the Longest?’ game? I’ve got an encyclopedic knowledge of these games, you know. But, let’s be real, this quiet game is as exciting as watching paint dry. Can we move onto something less dull, like brainstorming solutions maybe?”
Introverted Feeling (Fi): “I respect your need for silence if it’s a genuine call for introspection. But if it’s a passive-aggressive trick, well, let’s just say I’m not a fan of such emotional puppetry. Authenticity, my friend, is the name of the game.”
Extraverted Thinking (Te): “If your silence is a problem that needs to be solved, let’s find a solution. But if it’s a power play, well, I don’t play to lose, especially not in a game that’s as poorly designed as this one.”
Introverted Sensing (Si): “Ah, memories of past silent treatments! Like the time you zipped your lips after I mistakenly called your pet parrot a chicken. Or when you quietly seethed because I forgot our ‘three-month five-day’ anniversary. Good times, good times.”
Discover more about ENFPs: How ENFPs Pair Up Romantically with Every Myers-Briggs Personality Type
The ISTJ
The ISTJ, often known as “The Detective”, is all about duty, responsibility, and practicality. When faced with the silent treatment, they might initially mistake it for a “Do Not Disturb” sign. “Oh, you’re not talking? Perfect, I’ve got a bunch of stuff I’ve been meaning to catch up on. I’ll just leave you be to process your feelings then,” might be their logical train of thought. The ISTJ’s capacity to miss or intentionally ignore the passive-aggression in your silence is almost impressive. But once they realize it’s a ploy, they come down on you like a ton of bricks with their strong sense of right and wrong.
How the ISTJ’s Cognitive Functions Feel About the Silent Treatment:
Introverted Sensing (Si): “Silence, eh? Looks like a golden opportunity to catalogue these stamps or reorganize the pantry. Last time you went quiet, I managed to file all my tax returns!”
Extraverted Thinking (Te): “If your silence is a problem to be solved, I’d recommend a more efficient communication method. But hey, if this is your strategy, who am I to interrupt? I’ve got a task list that’s longer than a CVS receipt.”
Introverted Feeling (Fi): “I respect individual emotional experiences. But using silence as a manipulative tactic? Seems like a waste of perfectly good quiet time to me. Now, if you’ll excuse me, I’ve got a shed to build.”
Extraverted Intuition (Ne): “Are you mad? Or just contemplating the meaning of life? Do you hate me? Did you get a haircut I didn’t notice? If I think about this too long I’m gonna panic, so I’m getting back to my project.”
Discover more about ISTJs: Are ISTJs Rare? A Look at the Detective Personality Type
The ISFJ
Often hailed as “The Nurturer”, the ISFJ is all about harmony, compassion, and being highly tuned in to the feelings of others. When confronted with the silent treatment, their first instinct is to restore balance and happiness, like a gardener tending to a wilting plant that just needs a little extra love to bloom again. “Oh, you’re not talking? Do you need a cup of tea, a cozy blanket, or how about a freshly baked cookie? I heard chocolate chips can cure silence. No? Well, I tried!” They may utter to themselves. However, even the most nurturing of souls need some appreciation now and then. Occasionally, ISFJs themselves might deploy the silent treatment—not out of spite, mind you, but more as a quiet signal for others to recognize their sacrifices and feelings. It’s like they’re saying, “Spotlight’s on you, empathy. Time to do your thing!”
How the ISFJ’s Cognitive Functions Feel About the Silent Treatment:
Introverted Sensing (Si): “Ah, the silent treatment. Remember the last time this happened? I baked a pie and all was well. Maybe this time, a lasagna would do the trick. Or, wait… do you prefer mac ‘n’ cheese?”
Extraverted Feeling (Fe): “Silence can be loud, especially when it’s asking for some TLC. Let me whip up some comfort food, and we can talk it out over dinner.”
Introverted Thinking (Ti): “If your silence is a puzzle to solve, let’s find a way to put all the pieces back together. And if it’s an attempt to make me feel guilty, well, I have my own box of silence stashed away. But beware, it’s a collector’s edition.”
Extraverted Intuition (Ne): “You’re silent, huh? Are you mad or just deep in thought? Are you upset with me or just pondering why cats have nine lives?”
Find out more about ISFJs: Are ISFJs Rare? A Look at the Protector Personality Type
The ESTJ
The ESTJ, affectionately known as ‘The Administrator,’ is all about efficiency, order, and a well-executed plan. When met with the silent treatment, they’re likely to shake their heads and mutter, ‘This has got to be the most inefficient form of communication ever invented.’ They’d probably prefer a punch in the stomach; at least it’s straightforward and gets the point across. Yet, when their emotions are in overdrive, they too can retreat into silence. It’s not so much a ploy as it is a realization that expressing their feelings with words is like trying to herd cats—messy, chaotic, and liable to end with someone getting scratched.”
How the ESTJ’s Cognitive Functions Feel About the Silent Treatment:
Extraverted Thinking (Te): “Silence? Inefficient. But I suppose if it’s part of the process, I can make a little room in my planner. I’ve got a 15-minute slot around 12:30. We can squeeze it in then.”
Introverted Sensing (Si): “Oh, this silence thing again? Last time this happened, it took forever. I don’t get why we can’t just discuss the issue and move on, but okay, I’ll play along.”
Extraverted Intuition (Ne): “Silence… intriguing. Is this a new strategy? What’s the desired outcome? I’ll make some projections, but I’m warning you, my flowchart skills are unparalleled.”
Introverted Feeling (Fi): “Your silence stings, not gonna lie. I keep trying to get past it, but it’s like trying to run a marathon in a field of Legos, and I’m starting to feel vulnerable just trying to process it.”
The ESFJ
Ah, the ESFJ, or as we like to call them, “The Defenders.” They’re all about maintaining harmony and picking up on every subtle emotional cue in the room, like a finely tuned emotional weather radar. When faced with the silent treatment, they’re initially like a cat trying to do calculus – utterly confused. “Silence? From a human? But why? Where’s the data? How can I analyse your emotions if you’re not supplying any?” They might exclaim. Once they figure out the hidden intent behind your silence, it’s like they’ve decoded the Enigma machine – they immediately swing into action to restore peace (or berate you for not just talking about it). Remember, the ESFJ’s mission in life is to understand your feelings better than you do. Yet, even they can grow impatient with the silent treatment – it’s like trying to bake a cake without a recipe. Sure, they can wing it, but wouldn’t it be much easier if you just told them what’s going on?
How the ESFJ’s Cognitive Functions Feel About the Silent Treatment:
Extraverted Feeling (Fe): “This silence is like trying to interpret a blank canvas. I need emotions, people! I’m like a car without gas here!”
Introverted Sensing (Si): “The last time we faced the silent treatment, we bought flowers and that seemed to work. Perhaps this time, a heartfelt note might do the trick?”
Extraverted Intuition (Ne): “There are a hundred reasons you could not be talking. Did your mom die? Did I burn your toast this morning? Do you have cancer? What if you’re sleep walking? Should I wave my arms in front of your face?”
Introverted Thinking (Ti): “I know all the in’s and outs of how your mind works and I’m pretty sure there’s a logical fallacy holding up your righteous indignation.”
Find out more about ESFJs: 10 Signs of an Unhealthy ESFJ
The ISTP
Meet the ISTP, the “Vigilante,” who is all about hands-on experience, problem-solving, and a profound love for ‘quiet time.’ When the silent treatment crashes on their doorstep, they are likely to raise an eyebrow, give you a slight nod, and then dive right back into their latest project. “Oh, you’re not talking? That’s… interesting. Well, the carburetor won’t fix itself!” they might say.
They see your silence not as an emotional minefield to tiptoe around, but rather an opportunity to get on with their own thing. They figure that once you’ve battled out your emotional turmoil and are ready to talk it over like a civilized human being, you’ll let them know, preferably without any tears or irrational outbursts. They might even appreciate the silence, because let’s be honest, it’s much quieter in their workshop without someone chattering in their ear.
How the ISTP’s Cognitive Functions Feel About the Silent Treatment:
Introverted Thinking (Ti): “Silence, huh? Okay, gives me a chance to figure out how to code my own first-person shooter video game.”
Extraverted Sensing (Se): “Oh, no words, just body language? Excellent! I can read that tension in your shoulders like a book, and that crossed arms thing you’re doing is a real page-turner. Besides, silence means I can finally achieve a new high score in my game without any distractions. Let’s see how far I can throw this wrench!”
Introverted Intuition (Ni): “Silence…a sign of a brewing storm, perhaps? I sense there’s something deeper at play here. You’re not just silent; there’s a purpose behind it. I’ll process this further as I tune up this engine.”
Extraverted Feeling (Fe): “I can feel the emotional fluctuations changing, but I’m not sure what you want me to do about it. I know I have as likely a chance of making you explode as making you feel better, so I’m better off waiting till you express your feelings, hopefully in a drama-free way.”
Discover more about ISTPs: 24 Signs That You’re an ISTP, the Vigilante Personality Type
The ISFP
Introducing the ISFP, also known as “The Virtuoso,” who sees life as a colorful canvas waiting to be painted on. When the silent treatment is served up, they don’t crack under the pressure – quite the contrary.
The ISFP sees silence not as a weapon, but an invitation to retreat into their own private sanctuary where they can untangle their emotions. “Silence? Alright, I can work with that,” they might muse. “I need some time to understand where we stand, where you stand, and most importantly, where I stand.” They attempt to turn the silence into a masterpiece of understanding, exploring the subtleties of their feelings and the dynamics of the relationship.
However, when silence is used as a manipulative tool, the normally peace-loving ISFP may start to see red. “I don’t mind silence, but I do mind manipulation,” they might think. “It’s like trying to paint with a brush that has no bristles – it just smears the paint and ruins the artwork. Not cool.” To them, an honest conversation is like a palette of bright colors, and manipulation merely muddies the hues.
How the ISFP’s Cognitive Functions Feel About the Silent Treatment:
Introverted Feeling (Fi): “Ah, silence. A good chance to dive deep into my emotional ocean. What’s this feeling? Is it anger? Disappointment? Melancholy?”
Extraverted Sensing (Se): “Silence doesn’t mean inaction. It’s an opportunity to observe, to sense, to immerse myself in the environment. Maybe I should take a walk or strum out my feelings on a guitar.”
Introverted Intuition (Ni): “There’s a pattern in this silence. An underlying melody. I’ll need some time to figure out what’s really going on beneath the surface.”
Extraverted Thinking (Te): “Silence as a strategy? Hmm, that’s not very efficient. But if that’s the game we’re playing, I need a plan. How can I get you to just solve this problem with me?”
Find out more about ISFPs: The Unhealthy ISFP
The ESTP
Enter the ESTP, the “Daredevil,” who lives life in the fast lane and thrives on action and excitement. For them, the silent treatment isn’t just an inconvenience, it’s like being handed a puzzle with all the edge pieces missing. They don’t particularly enjoy the guessing game that comes with it. “Silence, really? That’s not going to fix the leak in the sink, is it?” they might quip.
While the silence may be deafening to others, the ESTP is likely to shrug it off and find something else to occupy their time. “You’re not talking? Cool. I’ll just be over here setting a new speed record on my bike,” they could say. They are doers, not dwellers; they’d rather burn off their frustration through physical activity or immerse themselves in a project that’s interesting them then try to coddle you into speaking.
The moment you’re ready to drop the act and talk it out, the ESTP is all ears. They prefer straightforward conversations and concrete solutions. But until then, they might just be busy perfecting their kickflip or beating their high score on their latest console game.
How the ESTP’s Cognitive Functions Feel About the Silent Treatment:
Extraverted Sensing (Se): “Silence? Fine. I’ll just soak up the world around me. Perhaps I’ll finally nail that tricky skateboard move or complete that challenging game level.”
Introverted Thinking (Ti): “This silence is like a machine that’s stopped working. I need to understand the cause, the problem at its core. But until then, I’ve got plenty to keep me busy.”
Extraverted Feeling (Fe): “I sense the emotional tension, but I need words, actions, something concrete to work with.”
Introverted Intuition (Ni): “Something is off. I can’t quite put my finger on it, but I know this silence means something more. Until it becomes clear, I’ll focus on something else.”
Find out more about ESTPs: Your ESTP Cognitive Function Guide
The ESFP
Now let’s move on to the ESFP, affectionately dubbed “The Champion,” who’s always ready to turn the everyday into an adventure. When encountered with the silent treatment, they don’t retreat into despondency. After all, silence isn’t a grim reaper of joy – it’s just another act in the grand play of life.
The ESFP, with their keen insight into motivations and emotional undercurrents, can sense the subtle shifts in the silent atmosphere. “There’s definitely a plot twist in this drama,” they may observe. “Time to figure out what’s really going on behind the curtain.” They’re like detectives with a flair for the dramatic, unearthing emotions and intentions hidden beneath the quiet.
However, they also know that there’s a time and place for everything. While they know how to analyze the subtext of the situation, they also understand the importance of levity. “You’re giving me the silent treatment? Fine. Who’s up for a silent dance-off?” they might challenge. For them, silence isn’t just a vacuum of dialogue – it’s a space filled with unspoken expressions, body language, and a soundtrack only they can hear. They can give you space to sort out your feelings, but they don’t want you to use the silent treatment as a power play. And they may turn the whole experience into a game (respectfully) until you’re wiling to be real with them.
How the ESFP’s Cognitive Functions Feel About the Silent Treatment:
Extraverted Sensing (Se): “Silence? That’s like a scene without any dialogue. But hey, that doesn’t mean the story isn’t progressing. I can sense the mood, see the expressions, feel the energy.”
Introverted Feeling (Fi): “There’s a motive behind this silence. I need to understand what it is, what it truly means.”
Extraverted Thinking (Te): “Silence might be unproductive, but it’s not insoluble. How can I effectively manage this energy and solve this problem?”
Introverted Intuition (Ni): “There’s a pattern in this silence, a rhythm in the quiet. It’s like a silent film, and I’m the one piecing the storyline together.”
Find out more about ESFPs: 24 Signs That You’re an ESFP, the Champion Personality Type
Subscribe to Our Newsletter
Want to discover more about personality type? Get the inside scoop with Susan Storm on all things typological, along with special subscriber freebies, and discounts on new eBooks and courses! Join our newsletter today!
Loved the ISTP description, spot on!
Thank you!! I’m glad you enjoyed it!
My ENTP ex would give me the silent treatment every time he was mad at me for something (and he’d deny being mad). But if I ever showed the slightest sign of unhappiness about anything, he wouldn’t let me stay quiet about it. He’d keep pestering me, demanding to know what was wrong. If whatever was wrong was not about him, he’d try to cheer me up. But if whatever was wrong *was* about him, he’d get mad (but denying it) and give me that silent treatment. As for myself, I may be quiet but I don’t give people silent treatments because I still respond to them if they talk to me. I have enough Fe to be considerate of people’s feelings, despite Fe not being in the INTJ’s function stack.
That’s interesting! I’m going to write another article about whether the types give the silent treatment. I know from talking to a lot of ExTPs that they tend to feel generally muddled and confused by their own feelings so they tend to stay quiet because they either need to say nothing or explode with a whole bunch of messy emotional data that they might later re-evaluate as being inaccurate. If they stay quiet then they don’t risk being “incorrect” about what they’re feeling. I think because they have Fe, they need to “extrovert” their feelings in order to make sense of them – so sometimes voice recording them, writing them down, or venting without being held accountable is good (in a safe way, of course). Trying to sort out feelings when you have Fe is difficult unless it’s externalized somehow. If you’re an INTJ, you can do the sorting process internally a bit more so you may have more cognizance of what’s actually going on for you and thus be able to talk about it a little more easily. Tertiary Fe is pretty rough when trying to understand those feelings on the inside.
I can’t speak for other ENTPs, but for my ex, I think his silent treatment was his way of getting back at whoever he was mad at. He wasn’t the type to be confrontational and yell. So instead he’d just be silent and ignore. My dad was an ENTP too, and he didn’t do the silent treatment. His style was more to talk angrily to himself, making sure everyone heard him while not directly talking to them.
Ooof…my dad isn’t an ENTP, but he did that too. Sometimes I would interrupt him and say, “you know we can hear you right?”
I’m an ESTP, and I definitely have to go do something fun or else I’ll just keep trying to make you talk with disastrous results.
I’m an INFJ that grew up with the silent treatment used as a weapon by a parent. Like for weeks. No recognition of my existence. As a result (OH, that childhood trauma!), I tend to become very quiet and removed after an argument, or even more so, an undeserved insult or inference. My silence is probably more about working through the situation myself than punishing the person who caused the hurt. The curse of seeing all sides of an issue is sometimes thinking myself into circles, not being able to tell what is right or wrong, upside down or right side up. I don’t let it drag on for hours and hours, though, if I care about the person. If I don’t really care for them, or the problem becomes constant, I just walk away – door slam, or, as I prefer to think of it, the vault closing. My husband is a an ISTP, so he just goes about his business while I think. If he thinks it’s going on for too long, he’ll just start talking to me, his way of saying, “It’s time to get over this or resolve it.”
Hit the nail on the head – nice work indeed!!!
I’m fine with people needing/wanting time and I don’t always need an explanation for that, BUT If I’m being manipulated it could absolutely be the end of our relationship – exactly this:
“Mature ENTJs will understand that sometimes people need space and time to process their feelings, but if there’s any tinge of manipulation to it they’ll get really turned off and possibly angry.”
Personally, I haven’t experienced much of the silent treatment in my family growing up or in more intimate connections, but that doesn’t stop me from encountering it in others from time to time, and it’s weird because it’s not something I’m used to encountering from my own upbringing. The Fe users in my family were pretty open about their feelings, and the Te users would know how to tell your opinions directly, so it’s weird to find it in other people. Though personally, I don’t mind a little waiting, because I spend a lot of time alone anyway. It’s just that being expected to make the first move first to guess what is wrong often goes badly for me, so I feel too afraid to talk about it at all. Then when I’m pressured to do so, I make multiple guesses, and each are wrong. I could make dozens and dozens of guesses, waiting for the other person to confirm one of these guesses, and yet 99% of the time, I guess it wrong. So there is this inevitable situation where people blow up enough after enough guesses, and just learn to speak to me directly, even if they avoid doing so with every other person. But someday, I want to be good enough to be able to do that guessing better, but I don’t know how to do it properly.