The Dark Side of the INTP Personality Type

The INTP dark side (queue Twilight Zone music). What is it? How can you recognize it?

Everyone has a dark side; insecurities they keep hidden, weaknesses they wish they didn’t have, or melancholy feelings that plague them. One question I’m often asked as an MBTI® practitioner is “What is the dark side of my personality type?”

I’ve written about the unhealthy INTP before, but today’s post is going to explore more of the secret vulnerabilities, struggles, and insecurities of this type and how those can manifest in dark or frustrating ways.

What is the INTP Personality Type?

If you’re new to type and happened to stumble onto this article, you might be wondering what INTP even means! The INTP is one of 16 Myers-Briggs® personality types. The INTP code tells us how this personality type likes to take in information and make decisions.

The acronym INTP stands for Introverted, Intuitive, Thinking, and Perceiving. In general terms, this means that people with this type are:

I – Focused on the internal world over the external world (Introversion)

N – Focused on abstract concepts rather than literal details (Intuition)

T – Make decisions by prioritizing logic (Thinking)

P – Prefer a flexible, open-ended approach to life (Perceiving)

INTPs are often called “Prodigies” or “Logicians”. They analyze and get behind the scenes of problems, trying to understand the principles of how the world works. Imagination is highly valued by this type, as well as originality. This type isn’t afraid to be unconventional or reflect in-depth on any particular problem. They’d rather be accurate than popular, truthful rather than charming. Famous INTPs include Albert Einstein, Charles Darwin, Marie Curie, and John Locke.

What are the Insecurities of the INTP?

Being Misunderstood

INTPs are more concerned with understanding than application. For this type, having a thorough knowledge of how something works is more important than using that information to achieve an external goal. INTPs amass information and analyze it to the point of overthinking.

The INTP’s talent for in-depth analysis can be impressive, but when it comes to expressing their ideas, INTPs can struggle to get the words out in the way they’d like. In their mind, the logic of their ideas is elegant and beautifully connected. But when they try to verbalize their ideas to others, they tend to feel irritated by how little people seem to understand. This can lead to feelings of frustration and loneliness over time. Some INTPs are left with the feeling that others are too “dim” to understand the complexity of their thoughts.

Swiss psychoanalyst Carl Jung said of this type, “When he does put his ideas into the world, he never introduces them like a mother solicitous for her children, but simply dumps them there and gets extremely annoyed if they fail to thrive on their own account.” (Psychological Types, 384)

Because INTPs are concerned with inner accuracy and less concerned with convincing the world outside, they often struggle to get their ideas across. People habitually underestimate them, starting as early as in elementary school. The struggle to express one’s self is often a lifelong ordeal for the INTP. Some INTPs befriend fellow NT or STP personality types who can draw their ideas out in a way that feels natural. When this happens, they are often able develop more confidence and poise with self-expression.

Internal vs External Excellence

Because INTPs care more about reaching an inner standard of understanding than achieving an external “reward,” they are typically less focused on grades or benchmarks and more focused on depth. Simultaneously, if they see a subject as irrelevant to them, they are often distracted by theories and ideas that are of more import to them personally. This often leads them to struggle with being understood in school. While many perform well on IQ tests they care little about following a prescribed formula or doing anything repetitive.

Typologist Paul D. Tieger states, “For most INTPs, their internal standards are much more interesting and important to them than any external standard imposed by others….Because internal standards matter so much more to INTPs than external ones, tests and report cards hold little meaning and rarely serve to motivate.” (Nurture by Nature, 155)

Because the world cares so much about external performance, INTPs can feel constantly belittled and devalued. This lead to frustration with authorities or anyone who has a tendency to “pull rank.”

Albert Einstein, an INTP, famously said: “To punish me for my contempt for authority, Fate made me an authority myself.”

Many INTPs will relate to Einstein’s distaste for authority. Rather than being in charge, INTPs often want to consult a variety of great minds and reach new depths of understanding. They care less about leading others and more about discovering new ideas.

“I find that [pursuing truth] is more important than trying to control people.” – Larry Page, Founder of Google

When INTPs put out their ideas in a convincing way, they can become trailblazers and catalysts who change everything. Larry Page and Sergey Brin, both INTPs, founded Google. Jimmy Wales, an INTP, formed Wikipedia. Abraham Lincoln, an INTP, changed the direction of U.S history.

INTPs have a lot to offer when they are able to express their inner vision in a way that others can understand. But because they often don’t command others’ attention with the same outspoken directness as certain other types, they can feel like they’re constantly pushed to the side. Because much of their ingenuity is internalized, people often don’t realize the originality and depth of their thoughts.

Feeling Unappreciated

As dominant Thinking types, INTPs value clarity of logic. But INTPs also feel. Their feeling function is called Extraverted Feeling and in many ways it appears as the opposite of Introverted Thinking, the INTP’s dominant function. This feeling side of the INTP revolves around having positive expression and rapport with others. Their feeling side craves warmth, harmony, and connection. However, INTPs often feel that they are not getting these things. They can be plagued by waves of intense self-consciousness and shyness, and many eschew social opportunities for fear of saying (or doing) the wrong thing or being misperceived.

Roger R. Pearman, EdD, says of this phenomenon, “In a compensatory mode (as with INTPs), Extraverted Feeling is driven so hard by the feeling of being disliked that it overwhelms all in the wave of its expression. This negative emotion has a needy quality that is so strong that individuals who see it coming get out of the way. This moving away by others inadvertently verifies the sense of being unappreciated. The emotions are well out of control for those who prefer Introverted Thinking. This causes anxiety and perhaps even some bitterness at the power of these emotions.” (I’m Not Crazy I’m Just Not You, 69)

This isn’t to say that INTPs are constantly emotionally needy and overwhelming. In fact, most are so afraid of their inner sensitivity being seen that they bottle up their feelings. During states of charged stress or moments of impulsivity, this Feeling side can erupt and INTPs may express intense emotions that surprise others with their magnitude. Unfortunately, this often leads to shame rather than understanding for the INTP. As a result, they keep trying to push the lid down on what they feel for fear of being misunderstood or mocked. The continued repression of their need for warmth and connection can lead to an inner resentment, insecurity, or self-critical nature. For some INTPs, they simply give up and stop trying to gain warmth from anyone and develop a more hostile, arrogant attitude, taking on the belief that nobody will understand them so they might as well not even try. Yet as much as INTPs may deny it, they deeply crave a sense of connection with others. They want to feel appreciated, heard, and considered.

Some INTPs form shallow or empty relationships in order to satisfy their desire for connection. While they are introverts, they are still humans and like all humans they have interpersonal needs. Connecting with others one-on-one can lower feelings of depression, loneliness, and anxiety as well as help individuals to refine their thoughts and ideas. While shallow relationships are temporarily appeasing, they don’t provide any deep or long-term satisfaction. Some INTPs keep their true selves hidden in order to maintain a social connection, assuming that their intellectual thoughts won’t be accepted or liked by others. This can lead to long-term feelings of emptiness, dissatisfaction, or grief.

Ways to Heal from the Dark Side:

INTPs have the potential to be catalysts of great change and visionaries of the future. But first, they must learn to accept themselves and their unique gifts. The best way to do this is to recognize their own internal genius, appreciate their complexity and value, practice open expression with others, and feel comfortable within their own skin.

Once INTPs break through these barriers to self-acceptance, they can begin to express their complex ideas more openly and confidently. They can learn to embrace their need for connection with others and find ways to get their emotional needs met in healthy ways. When INTPs are able to do this, they become a force to be reckoned with – original, insightful, and passionate people who can make a lasting impact on the world.

Some Steps to Take to Grow:

• As an INTP, it’s natural for you to sequester yourself away and pursue knowledge and understanding. This is valuable. Make sure you’re getting enough time for this in your daily life and your schedule isn’t jam-packed with external obligations and demands.
• Remember that even though you’re an introvert, you do have an extroverted side as well. Ample alone time is important, but if you become too isolated and reclusive you will struggle to bring your ideas to fruition and form meaningful connections with people and the world around you.
• Take time to brainstorm, create, and innovate with others. Find communities where your critical thinking and imagination are valued. You could join a book club, a debate team, or take a class on a subject that interests you. There are hundreds of online communities that may hold similar interests to your own. Practice sharing your ideas and theories with others and engaging in the external world. The more you do this, the easier it will become to put yourself out there, grow in your discoveries, and gain valuable relationships.
• Try new things. As an NP personality type, exposing yourself to new ideas, locations, and people inspires growth. The challenge and novelty of being in a new situation that you aren’t used to can help break down the self-limiting beliefs and fear that keep you from expressing yourself openly. Do something new every day, even if it’s uncomfortable. This could be as simple as going to a new coffee shop or as complex as talking to someone at work you’ve never talked to before.
• Read biographies of other inspiring INTPs. You may find that their struggles provide you with a feeling of comfort and solidarity. You’ll also be inspired by how they pushed through hardships to make positive changes in the world. You can see a list of famous rumored INTPs on IDRLabs.com
• Express your emotions through writing poetry, journaling, or even singing (if you feel comfortable doing so). This will help you to understand your emotions and give you greater self-awareness. Read your journal or poetry back to yourself; hearing it in your own voice can help you to process it more accurately.
• Find a friend or family member that you trust to share your feelings with. Ask for their thoughts and accept their affirmation or empathy. If they do have criticisms to share, don’t let that dissuade you from reaching out. Make sure that the person you share your feelings with is someone with good intentions who really wants the best for you.
• If possible, find other NT personality types to engage with. These types can help you to break out of your shell and will likely enjoy hearing your ideas and theories, even if they don’t always agree. They may provide an outlet you need for intellectual stimulation and challenge.

What Are Your Thoughts on the INTP Dark Side?

Do you feel like you’re dealing with an INTP’s dark side? These types have a unique set of gifts and challenges, but with the right strategies they can become powerful contributors to society. By taking time for themselves, engaging in meaningful relationships, and trying new things, INTPs can unlock their potential. I for one am grateful for the INTPs in my life – they’ve helped me to see things from a different perspective and have made the world a more interesting place.

Do you have any perspectives or thoughts you’d like to share? Let us and other readers know in the comments!

Other Articles You Might Enjoy:

How INTPs Say “I Love You”

The 10 Best Careers for INTPs

24 Signs That You’re an INTP, the Prodigy Personality Type

References:

Jung, C. G., (1990), Psychological Types (9^th Edition), Princeton-Bollingen.

Pearman, Roger. R., (2010), I’m Not Crazy I’m Just Not You (2nd Edition), Nicholas Brealey Publishing

Tieger, Paul D. & Barbara Barron (1997), Nurture by Nature: Understand Your Child’s Personality Type – And Become a Better Parent, Little, Brown and Company